After Whyatt loses his first tooth, his mother tells him that the Tooth Fairy can come and take his tooth, but Whyatt has to choose if he wants to keep it. Super Why and his friends decide to ask the Tooth Fairy herself, so they set off to meet her in person. With a little bit of magic (and a little bit of floss) the Super Readers are able to get their questions answered. The super story answer is NOTE.

DVD Release: The Story of the Tooth Fairy and 3 other storybook adventures